India’s Supreme Court rejects bail for nun held seven months without charge

31 January 2019

Appears in: Archdiocesan News

India’s Supreme Court rejected bail for a Missionaries of Charity nun arrested nearly seven months ago on suspicion of child trafficking. reported the top court turned down the plea from Missionaries of Charity Sister Concilia Jan. 29 on grounds that police had not yet pressed charges in the case. However, the court left the door open for her to file another application and also told the police to file formal charges soon.

On July 5, Sister Concilia, who headed the Nirmal Hriday (tender heart) home for unmarried mothers in Jharkhand’ s state capital, Ranchi, initially was remanded in judicial custody for 14 days.

The 61-year-old nun was arrested along with a staff member at the home following complaints that the staff member accepted money from a childless couple to give them a baby and then failed to do so.

Sister Concilia, who has diabetes, has been denied bail twice, prompting her plea to the Supreme Court.

“We feel very sad that an innocent and physically unwell nun is behind bars,” said Bishop Theodore Mascarenhas, secretary-general of the Indian bishops’ conference.

“We are pained that an aged innocent nun remains in jail when murderers and other hardcore criminals get bail,” the bishop told

The denial of the bail comes amid media reports that the Jharkhand state government has revoked the order’s license to run the Nirmal Hriday home. Authorities also cancelled licences for 15 other child care centres run by other organizations, following a state-level investigation into children’s care homes.

The nuns told on Jan. 31 that they have not received any official notification that their licence had been revoked.

The Missionaries of Charity is a Roman Catholic religious congregation established in 1950 by Mother Teresa, now known as St. Teresa of Calcutta. In 2012 it consisted of more than 4,500 religious sisters.

Christian leaders say projecting missionaries as criminals is a tactic used by Hindu groups in their attempt to make India a Hindu-only nation. They believe such cases will keep villagers away from missioners and Christian institutions.


This is default text for notification bar
This is default text for notification bar